Who We Are and What We Do
           



Restitution

Restitution is a process by which offenders are held accountable for the financial losses they have caused to the victims of their crimes. The restitution payment is the sum of money paid by the offender to the victim to balance this monetary debt.

Without restitution, a victim may be financially devastated by the crime committed against them. A victim's financial losses can also contribute to their experience of trauma and frustration with the criminal and juvenile justice systems. On the other hand, receiving a restitution payment can make a victim feel that the justice system is working on their behalf to ensure they are justly compensated for their losses. Moreover, restitution, as a part of the sentence or a condition of community supervision, is an essential aspect of holding offenders accountable for their crimes.

Restitution is considered to be a "core" victim right which is crucial to help victims reconstruct their lives in the aftermath of a crime. In recent years, restitution has been made mandatory for those convicted of federal crimes.

Goals

The goals of restitution include:

  • Providing compensation to victims who suffer financial losses as a result of crime. Such losses may include out-of-pocket expenses for medical or mental health treatment, property loss or damage, sexual assault examinations, HIV testing, participation in justice processes, and funeral cost.
  • Holding offenders accountable for their actions, specifically those that cause financial harm to victims.

Implementation

Appropriate restitution orders are based on information provided by victims to the court about out-of-pocket losses and information about offenders' financial status and earning capacity. Victim input is usually gathered through either victim impact statements or pre-sentence investigations. Victims often need assistance to prepare complete, accurate documentation of their immediate and projected financial losses resulting from the crime. Such assistance can be provided by victim advocates, prosecution staff, or probation/parole personnel.

The ordering, collecting, and disbursing of restitution requires strong collaborative efforts among many justice agencies. Justice officials need to practice "due diligence" in seeking court- or parole-ordered restitution payments from offenders. Records of restitution judgments should be incorporated into offenders' case files at the court, probation, incarceration/detention, and parole stages of the criminal and juvenile justice processes. Victims should be advised of the types of remedies the system can pursue when offenders fail to comply with restitution orders, which include, but are not limited to, converting restitution orders to civil judgments, extending the terms of probation/parole until restitution is paid, asset forfeiture, garnishment or attachment, income withholding orders, and revocation of probation/parole, in some cases.

Lessons Learned

Reports around Illinois since 1999 show that juveniles involved with face to face restorative practices pay a much larger percentage of restitution than those otherwise ordered to pay. A study involving 6,336 formal juvenile probation cases in Utah, conducted by the National Center for Juvenile Justice, found the use of restitution associated with significant reductions in recidivism among certain juvenile offenders. Juveniles agreeing to pay restitution as an informal disposition, as well as those formally ordered to pay restitution, returned to court significantly less often than juveniles who did not pay restitution (OJJDP, 1992).

Practices