When it comes to matters of personal safety and the law, two terms often arise: protective order vs restraining order. These legal tools are designed to help keep individuals safe from abuse, harassment, or threats. However, many people confuse the two or use them interchangeably—even though they differ significantly in purpose, scope, and enforcement.
In this article, we’ll break down the key differences between a protective order and a restraining order, explain how each one works, who can file for them, and what happens if they’re violated. Whether you’re seeking legal protection or simply curious about how the law works in these situations, this article will help you understand everything in plain language.
What Is a Protective Order?
A protective order—also called an order of protection—is a legal document issued by a court to protect someone who feels threatened, abused, or harassed. It is most commonly used in domestic violence situations and is usually filed against a family member, spouse, partner, or someone the person has had an intimate relationship with.
What Does It Do?
A protective order can require the offender to:
- Stay away from the victim’s home, workplace, or school
- Avoid any kind of contact, including phone calls, texts, emails, or social media
- Move out of a shared home
- Surrender firearms
- Attend counseling or treatment programs
Protective orders are usually part of criminal or family law cases and are enforceable by the police.
What Is a Restraining Order?
A restraining order is also a court order, but it’s broader in scope and not always related to violence or abuse. It can be used in civil matters like property disputes, business conflicts, or neighbor issues. Restraining orders can prevent someone from doing certain things—like contacting another person, coming near a property, or taking actions like selling assets.
Types of Restraining Orders
There are generally two types:
- Civil Restraining Order – Used in non-criminal cases, such as between neighbors, co-workers, or business partners.
- Criminal Restraining Order – Often tied to a criminal case where the defendant must avoid contact with the victim or witnesses.
Restraining orders are sometimes used in divorce or custody cases too, especially when there’s fear of conflict or interference.
Key Differences in Protective Order vs Restraining Order
Let’s break it down simply:
| Feature | Protective Order | Restraining Order |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Protects against domestic violence or abuse | Prevents certain actions or contact |
| Relationship Required? | Yes – intimate/family/domestic | No – can be anyone |
| Filed Under | Criminal or family court | Civil or criminal court |
| Police Enforced? | Yes | Sometimes (depends on type) |
| Duration | Temporary or long-term (up to years) | Usually temporary, renewable |
| Firearm Restrictions? | Yes, often required | Sometimes, not always |
| Violations Lead to? | Criminal charges/arrest | Contempt of court or criminal charges |
When to Seek a Protective Order
You should consider a protective order if:
- You are being abused by a spouse, partner, family member, or someone you live with.
- You’re being stalked or harassed by a former romantic partner.
- You’re afraid for your safety and need legal protection to keep the other person away.
- There has been a history of violence or threats.
Protective orders are serious legal tools and are designed for situations where someone is in danger or experiencing harm.
When to Seek a Restraining Order
You might consider a restraining order if:
- You’re in a legal dispute and need to prevent someone from contacting or interfering with you.
- You’re dealing with a neighbor, co-worker, or acquaintance who’s harassing you.
- You need to prevent someone from selling property or draining bank accounts during a divorce.
- You’re involved in a business or contract dispute.
Restraining orders are more flexible in nature and can be tailored to suit a wide range of situations, not just those involving violence.
How to File for Each
Filing a Protective Order
- Go to your local family court or courthouse.
- Fill out the petition for a protective order.
- Provide details about your relationship, incidents of abuse, and why you need protection.
- A judge may issue a temporary protective order (TPO) immediately.
- A court hearing will be scheduled (usually within 10-30 days) for a final order.
Filing a Restraining Order
- Visit your local civil court or court clerk’s office.
- Fill out a request or petition for a restraining order.
- Specify what actions you want the other person restrained from.
- The court may issue a temporary order until the hearing.
- Attend the hearing to request a permanent or extended order.
What Happens After You File?
Once filed:
- The other party is served with notice of the order and the upcoming court hearing.
- A temporary order (if granted) takes effect immediately.
- You both attend a hearing, where you present your evidence and testimony.
- The judge decides whether to grant a final order, which may last months or years depending on the case.
You should gather:
- Photos, texts, emails
- Police reports
- Witnesses (if possible)
- Medical records or proof of harm
Enforcement and Penalties
Protective Orders
Violating a protective order is a crime. Penalties can include:
- Immediate arrest
- Jail time
- Fines
- Criminal charges for contempt
Police take these orders seriously, and victims should call 911 if they believe the order has been violated.
Restraining Orders
Violating a restraining order may lead to:
- Civil or criminal contempt charges
- Fines
- In some cases, jail
It depends on the type of restraining order and the local laws in your area. If the court determines the violation is severe or repeated, the penalties can increase.
How Long Do These Orders Last?
Protective Orders
- Temporary Orders – Usually last 1 to 3 weeks until the hearing.
- Final Orders – Can last months, 1 year, or more. Some can be made permanent depending on the case.
Restraining Orders
- Temporary Restraining Orders (TROs) – Typically last 15-30 days.
- Permanent Restraining Orders – May last 1 to 5 years but can be extended upon request.
You can usually renew the order before it expires if you still feel threatened or need protection.
Can They Be Modified or Dismissed?
Yes.
Modifying the Order
If circumstances change, you can ask the court to:
- Add or remove restrictions
- Change the distance requirements
- Include or exclude locations or people
Dismissing the Order
Either party can request a dismissal, but the judge must approve it. Courts often won’t lift a protective order unless they are confident the person seeking dismissal is not doing so under pressure or fear.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I get both a protective order and a restraining order?
Yes, depending on the situation. For example, you might get a protective order for personal safety and a restraining order in a related civil dispute.
Do I need a lawyer?
Not always, but it’s recommended—especially if the other party has legal representation or if the case is complex.
Are these orders valid in other states?
Yes, thanks to the Full Faith and Credit Clause of the U.S. Constitution. Most states honor protective and restraining orders issued elsewhere.
Can I file an order against a co-worker or boss?
Yes, but usually that falls under a civil restraining order. You can also report to HR or workplace authorities.
What if the other person contacts me even if I didn’t ask them to?
Still a violation. You cannot waive a court order—it remains enforceable until the court says otherwise.
Conclusion
Understanding the difference in protective order vs restraining order is important when you’re seeking safety, justice, or peace of mind. While both serve to create legal boundaries, they are used in different contexts and carry different legal weight.
A protective order is generally used in personal, family, or domestic violence cases where physical safety is at risk. It is enforced strongly by law enforcement and comes with severe penalties if violated.
A restraining order, on the other hand, is often used in civil matters and can be customized to limit contact, behavior, or actions between individuals or parties. It’s more about keeping things fair, safe, and under control during a dispute.
If you ever feel unsafe or threatened, don’t hesitate to reach out to local authorities or a legal aid organization. The law is there to protect you—and understanding how these tools work is the first step in protecting yourself or someone you care about.
No comment